For the past half-century, one of the most influential, respected, and popular scholars of modern Indian history has been Sumit Sarkar. When his first monograph, The Swadeshi Movement in Bengal 1903–1908 (1973), appeared, it showed something of a paradigm shift within its genre. As one eminent historian put it: “Very few monographs, if any, have ever rivalled the meticulous research and the thick description that characterised this book, or the lucidity of its exposition and the persuasive power of its overall argument.” Ten years later Sarkar published Modern India 1885–1947, in which the synthesis and critique of everything significant that had been written about the period was hailed as admirably cogent and lucid.